Well, there are fanzines and there are fanzines. After this long in the business, here at Beans! we've reached the conclusion that they can all be categorised into about a dozen distinct and recognisable types. So here is...

The GOOD FANZINE GUIDE

  • The Bland Leader
    We have to start with the Bland Leader, simply because there are so many of them. So called because it's just dull, dull, dull. Match reports and pious editorials are staple features as are obscure statistics and impenetrable in-'jokes'. The Bland Leader always contains the standard 'All views are those of the individual contributors. Right of reply guaranteed' type disclaimer, but surely 'WARNING: Could cause drowsiness. Do not drive or operate machinery within four hours of reading' would be more appropriate. As we noted above, there are so many of these that it would be unfair to single out examples, but be sure to steer clear of anything where the title consists of the club's nickname followed by the word 'Review' - it's almost certainty a Supporters' Club newsletter of the most turgid kind!

  • The Pro Job
    The Premier League big brother of the Bland Leader. Beautifully produced on glossy paper; professionally typeset, professionally written with professional standard photographs and cartoons, it might as well be the programme. Usually it's not any more interesting anyway. For typical examples you need took no further than most Spurs or Arsenal 'zines. But never fear, for right at the opposite end of the scale, we have...

  • The Non-League Mimeograph
    By far the best joke in Farnborough's Simon's Haircut is always the one on their inside back cover which reads 'Registered at the Post Office as a few scrappy bits of A4 stapled together.' And though their offering is actually far from this, it neatly sums up the style and appearance of several publications from beneath the pinnacle of the Conference/Premier Beazer/Diadora/UniBond non-League axis. But despite being filled with a host of typographical, grammatical and spelling errors (though still not as many as in Team Talk), in many ways the Non-League Mimeograph represents the heart and soul of fanzines. Originated on an ancient manual typewriter with a dodgy ribbon and reproduced on an old stencil machine, its initial print run is about fifty and in the unlikely event of their selling out, the editor can run one off specially for you. Low tech and proud of it, they think an Apple Mac is a pale green raincoat, but an electronic typewriter would probably cause a terminal orgasm. For some typical examples see Herne Bay's Field of Dreams or the revived South Liverpool Southender/Heckler.

  • The Literary Masterpiece
    The Literary Masterpiece reads as if every single one of its writers got a double first in English at Oxford... and it knows it! Full of self conscious references to its own lexical errors, split infinitives and the like, it features metaphors unsurpassed since the days of Raymond Chandler and a prose style that Martin Amis would die for. So packed with allusions to popular culture that even Danny Baker would have trouble taking them all in, and to classical culture that Richard Baker would have problems with those. The classic of its kind is Boston United's late lamented From Behind Your Fences, but following close behind in the literary stakes is...

  • The Dada Darling
    ...or the Master of Surreality. The Dada Darling is so far off the wall even a bucketful of Solvite couldn't get it back on there. It eschews match reports for an original mixture of the off-beat, the bizarre, the curious and the unusual. The Reeves and Mortimer of the fanzine world in that done well it can be brilliantly imaginative and hilarious, but done badly, can be puerile, embarrassing and self indulgent. Two prime examples of the good are Gillingham's Brian Moore's Head... and Morecambe's Corpus Christie.

  • The Left Whinger
    Slough Town's much missed Rebels Without A Clue remains the model for all aspiring 'zines of this type. The Left Whinger wears its politics on its sleeve and all the way through. Politically correct to a fault, you won't find any sign of racism, sexism, regionalism or any other ism come to that in here, but what you will find is plenty of entertainingly vicious abuse directed the town's sitting Tory MP and their nearest local rivals on the football field. Which brings us neatly on to...

  • The All ß@$*@®¶$ are ß@$*@®¶$
    The All ß@$*@®¶$ are ß@$*@®¶$ exists solely to slag off the supporters and indeed everything connected with any club within about a fifty mile radius of their own. Indeed, this type of fanzine can never bring itself to print the names of these rivals, and it is something of a convention to replace the vowels of their name, or even the entire word with the exception of the first and last letters, with asterisks. Fans of these rivals are always 'scum, slime or $#¡*', etc. There are lots of these fanzines, but they seem to be particularly prevalent among lower division Nationwide League clubs from the North West; the Burnleys, Prestons and Rochdales of this world.

  • The Rag Mag
    The illegitimate second cousin of the All ß@$*@®¶$ are ß@$*@®¶$, the Rag Mag makes no concession to anything even slightly sensible, and gets by on a diet of jokes, jokes and, er... more jokes. Fine as far as it goes, but as there isn't an infinite supply of gags, this type of publication usually only survives for one or two issues, but it does provide a good source of material for our next category... If you want a good example try and track down a copy of an obscure Bishop's Stortford 'zine Mellow and Dry.

  • The Ricicle Thief
    So called because it steals all its snap, crackle and pop from other fanzines and tries to pass it off as its own. Again, there are far too many of these to mention here, but probably the most plagiarised item in the entire history of fanzines is the What The Commentators Really Mean series of cartoons from Brian Moore's Head...

  • The Old Campaigner
    The Old Campaigner is never satisfied. Neither the manager, the players or the board - especially the board - ever come up to standard in their eyes. They could have Jack Walker as chairman, Bob Paisley as manager and a team that makes Brazil circa 1970 took like a bunch of Sunday pub league cloggers, but still they'd be calling for someone's head on a plate. Furthermore, the Campaigner seems to know everything that goes on at the club even before the club know it themselves. The best examples of the type are Kettering's Poppies at the Gates of Dawn and the sadly missed Codhead from Fleetwood Town.

  • The Master Tactician
    A close relative of the Old Campaigner, but all its detail is reserved for endless tactical discussions and remedies for the failings of their team. So involved is the minutiae of all this stuff that probably even Charles Hughes and Terry Venables wouldn't understand it. Thankfully, there aren't too many of these though I did once see a Derby County fanzine (whose name escapes me now) that had me so perplexed after just two pages that I had to give up.

  • The Endangered Species
    Not really, but it's akin to one in that you may only see a new edition once or, if you're very lucky, twice a year. Cheltenham Town's The Robin is such a rare bird. Alternatively, the Endangered Species may sometimes go into hibernation for a while. Just as you think it really has gone into extinction, it will surprise you by bringing out a new edition when you least expect it - about two years after the last one.
Issue 023 - August 1995

back

top

next